A structure spanning an area of 220 square meters, containing eight rooms, has been uncovered in the Jerusalem Walls National Park. The structure includes an altar, a standing stone (matzeva), and even a wine press. In one of the rooms, a mysterious V-shaped carving was found on the floor. A new article published this week in the Atiqot journal by the Israel Antiquities Authority suggests that the structure served ritual purposes during the time the Temple stood on the Temple Mount, just a few hundred meters to the north. It appears the structure was in use until it was suddenly abandoned and sealed off, possibly due to Hezekiah’s reform, which centralized worship in one place—likely the Temple Mount itself. This raises the question: why would there have been multiple sanctuaries in such close proximity?
One hypothesis is that the structure served as a temple for a deity other than Yahweh. Why else would two sanctuaries for the same deity be needed so close to each other? If this is true, it forces us to acknowledge the polytheistic nature of Judah at that time. While it is known from the Bible itself that idol worship occurred in Jerusalem, it is unclear whether this polytheism was a deviation from a monotheistic norm or whether the kingdom started as polytheistic and only later transitioned to monotheism. Below, I present several hypotheses that might suggest the latter scenario.
In parallel cultures, “sacred complexes” were common, both due to the unique topography of specific sites and because these places had multiple patrons. Immediate examples include Delphi, Olympia, and Knossos—all complexes featuring sacred mountains, springs, various altars for different gods, monuments, and social institutions. This doesn’t necessarily mean there was a direct connection between the rituals, but it sets a precedent. Typically, the head of a pantheon was worshipped alongside his consort. For example, in Olympia, there were temples for both Zeus and Hera. Why, then, could there not be one temple for Yahweh and another for his consort, Asherah, in Jerusalem?
Sacred mountains also exist in Israel, and many feature sanctuaries, some with sacred caves and springs. In fact, the combination of a tree, cave, spring, and mountain is common in pagan sanctuaries that were later adapted to monotheism. Examples can be found near the sources of the Jordan River and in the Galilee (e.g., Banias, Mount Meron, and Arbel). What sanctifies such natural features is their distinctiveness in the landscape. These “unique” sites often retained their sacred status in later religions due to continuity from their pagan past. Monotheistic religions sanctified these places with narratives denying their pagan roots, but often the myths surrounding monotheistic figures are based on older, pagan myths. This likely happened in Jerusalem as well, making the discovery of such a temple a potential revolutionary insight.
In the case of Jerusalem, there are several natural phenomena that hint at pagan worship, particularly in the so-called “Holy Basin” area. One example is the Gihon Spring. Evidence suggests that pulsating springs were considered sacred, with beliefs that their pulsations were caused by entities residing within, drawing the water in and releasing it. The Temple Mount features the Foundation Stone, regarded as the “navel of the world,” akin to the omphalos at Delphi. Beneath it lies a cave: the Well of Souls. Let us return to this shortly.
Is there archaeological evidence of activity in these locations predating the Judahite period? In short, no. Due to the sensitivity of the Temple Mount, and the tangible dangers faced by archaeologists investigating the site, no conclusive research has been conducted. The only significant investigation was carried out by Montague Parker, who barely escaped with his life. He followed earlier excavations by Charles Warren in areas like Warren’s Shaft in the City of David and the Gihon Spring, where Bronze Age settlement remains were found. While this doesn’t prove anything definitive, it hints at early activity in a location suspected of prior sanctity.
Parker aimed to uncover the Ark of the Covenant. To this end, he secured access through bribes to excavate the Well of Souls. The limited findings he brought back led some scholars to speculate that the site housed a Jebusite temple predating the First Temple. However, Parker’s presence was discovered, and an enraged crowd nearly lynched him. He escaped by sheer luck, and no one has since dared to explore the idea further. Excavations at the Temple Mount have primarily been destructive, erasing evidence of pre-Islamic or pre-Judahite sanctity. It is possible that deeper evidence remains undiscovered, but such findings are unlikely ever to come to light. Thus, we must focus on what has already been uncovered. For example, some hypothesize that the cave was a Jebusite temple or a sacred burial site. Similar caves have parallels in sacred complexes like Knossos.
In Crete, two famous mountains feature sacred caves. Mount Ida houses the Psychro Cave, where infant Zeus was hidden from Cronus, who sought to kill him. To mask the infant’s cries, a group of dancers called the Kouretes performed war dances in a trance outside the cave. Similar dances appear in other Earth Mother cults, like Cybele’s, though for different reasons. Another notable mountain is Mount Juktas near Knossos, said to be the burial site of Zeus. From a distance, the mountain resembles a reclining man, representing Zeus’ image. However, Zeus is both buried and resurrected—a motif reminiscent of Jesus, possibly hinting at a connection between Knossos and Jerusalem.
On Mount Juktas, a king of Crete, known as the Anax, was said to retreat annually for solitude. This tradition recalls King Minos’ ascent to the mountain to “consult with the gods” The cave temple may have been the entrance to the Labyrinth, underscoring its sanctity. You can read more about the Knossos tradition in Rodney Castleden’s book The Knossos Labyrinth: A New View of the ‘Palace of Minos’ at Knossos.
The Labyrinth, as you recall, housed the Minotaur, where human sacrifices were sent. Those lost, captured, or killed there might still be heard crying for help. Incidentally, human sacrifice is associated with the Kouretes’ dances in the Ida Cave and was practiced in Crete and Jerusalem, particularly in the Valley of Hinnom.
The story of the priest-king who enters the holy of holies once a year to consult with the gods echoes the High Priest’s entry into the Holy of Holies on Yom Kippur. Thus, the Holy of Holies might itself be a cave temple or labyrinthine cave. According to a medieval Muslim belief, souls awaiting Judgment Day can be heard in the Well of Souls, as it is considered an entrance to Hell (Gehenna)—unless one associates the entrance with the Valley of Hinnom. Conversely, the Foundation Stone, situated above the Well of Souls, is regarded as the navel of the earth, a gateway to Paradise. This parallels the omphalos at Delphi, located at the center of the Pythian temple.
The High Priest’s safe return from the Holy of Holies on Yom Kippur was marked by a celebratory festival. This strongly resembles the Kouretes’ trance dances or other Greek processions. Similarly, the Simchat Beit HaShoeva (Water Drawing Celebration) during Sukkot, involving ecstatic dances, commemorated the water libation ceremony using water drawn from the Gihon Spring. Could the spring or its waters, then, not be considered sacred?
In Christianity, sacred springs are associated with the Annunciation of Jesus’ birth by the angel Gabriel to Mary. Similarly, a Crusader tradition associates the Well of Souls with the announcement of John the Baptist’s birth. In Psalm 22, an infant is described as being “drawn from the womb” ("gohi mibaten") Could the Gihon Spring symbolize a birth cave for some deity or a dwelling for a fertility goddess? We cannot know for sure.
This is the context for the theory that the temple near the Gihon Spring in the City of David was a cultic site. This interpolation leads us to speculate that the Gihon Spring is “Yahweh’s birth cave” and that the Holy of Holies is the place where He “ascended to heaven,” much like the Muslim tradition regarding Muhammad and the Foundation Stone.
In conclusion: What is the connection between Minoan culture and worship in Jerusalem? Several researchers, including Beno Rothenberg and Michael Astour in his book Hellenosemitica, have argued for a close connection between Canaan and Crete. Michael Astour claims that the Cretans were actually Canaanites who migrated to Crete, bringing their worship practices to Knossos—a name he posits is a variation of the Hebrew word “Knesset” (assembly). Beno Rothenberg suggests that the Kenites made the reverse journey, perhaps moving from Crete to Edom, and argues that there is a strong link between Yahweh and Minoan worship, as Yahweh is the deity of the Kenites.
From the fusion of these two theories—still speculative and primarily based on fragments of evidence and intriguing but questionable etymologies—it could be inferred that Jerusalem was, in fact, the origin of the worship at Knossos. Consequently, the Temple Mount might be sacred due to its shape, and the Holy of Holies could be seen as the entrance to both Paradise and Hell, as suggested earlier.
הצטרפו לרשימת התפוצה שלנו

כתיבת תגובה