From Yahwism to Judaism

Prof. Yonatan Adler from the Department of Land of Israel Studies and Archaeology at Ariel University is expected to publish his second book very soon, in the coming weeks, through Cambridge University Press. In the first two weeks after its release, it will be available for free download as an e-book. To mark the occasion, he was hosted both on the MythVision Podcast channel and the History Valley channel—both channels that are, in spirit, close to this blog. Which is wonderful, and also the fact that Ariel University itself is waving the flag that “alternative” channels in biblical studies are echoing Adler’s theories—likely to irritate not only the religiously observant but, above all, mainstream biblical scholars who assume that the Torah was formulated and disseminated at the end of the Kingdom of Judah, or at most in the days of the Return to Zion. Incidentally, according to Wikipedia at least (but I believe it’s true), Prof. Adler himself has rabbinical training, which makes his research, in general, somewhat odd in the Orthodox context—for example, that in biblical times people did not observe the laws of kashrut. How can that be? Not even in the period when the Book of Deuteronomy was found and Josiah imposed its implementation on all Israel?

Adler’s research eventually developed into a book published about two years ago by Yale University Press, The Origins of Judaism. The book argued that there is no evidence whatsoever that observance of the Torah’s commandments was widespread before the Hasmonean period. Or more precisely, if you look for it archaeologically—there isn’t any. The only evidence is in the texts, but you can’t prove that the texts aren’t fictional. Archaeology proves the opposite: the evidence for observance of the commandments appears clearly only in the Hasmonean period. Therefore, we might—and he emphasizes, we might; he didn’t want to be dogmatic—conclude that the commandments were “invented” and implemented only in this period. No kashrut, no ritual purity, no tefillin, no mezuzot, no synagogues, not even Jewish worship in the Temple, and certainly no prohibition against images of any kind for God. If so, one can understand that the Hasmoneans felt it important to instill a sort of national Torah for their subjects, and they did this through adopting a legal code. In the Hellenistic period, law was an important concept; the Greeks prided themselves on it, and a founder of laws was considered a founder—a kind of Solon. So Ezra was such a figure.

He himself doesn’t argue this, but others do—that the model wasn’t necessarily Solon but rather Pythagoras, as someone whose every utterance is sacred and cannot be altered, because he is presumed to be right. And even what he didn’t say—if attributed to him—is true, especially among Neo-Pythagoreans who prided themselves on being filled with Pythagoras’s spirit. So even if he didn’t say it, he surely would have. This principle is called ipse dixit and was widespread in the Hellenistic period, particularly in the Alexandrian school.

Before I say what he claims in the new book, it’s important to define two concepts: The first is Yahwism. This refers to a soft polytheism, meaning Yahweh is the chief god but not necessarily the only one, and it doesn’t mean he doesn’t have a consort. It’s not hard polytheism—the consort of Yahweh is not necessarily separate from him but is simply an aspect of him, what is called henotheism. Indeed, we see at the Elephantine temple that the goddess Anat receives the suffix “Yahu,” becoming Anat-Yahu. Yet still, if one wants to appropriate other cults of the Mother Goddess, there’s no principled problem, and indeed portraits connected to Athena appear in Judah in the pre-Hasmonean period (4th century BCE)—such as the Gorgoneion and the owl. Beyond the possibility that Yahweh was perhaps the divine essence but had several aspects, the worship itself was not centralized, and we also see temples outside Jerusalem, for example in Samaria and of course in Elephantine. Were they legitimate temples? Perhaps—it’s impossible to know, but the fact that the Elephantine temple defines itself as a Jewish temple is telling. Moreover, the biblical rituals themselves suggest that until the time of Ezra and Nehemiah, Jews had not yet observed every law meticulously, and certainly after Josiah’s reforms they still reverted to idolatry. Did the reform fail? Or was there never truly a reform? Or perhaps there was a reform, but not the one we know?

It’s worth noting that Chris Bennett himself claims something similar in "Cannabis: Lost Sacrament of the Ancient World". Even Ezra did not act as the reform tried to portray itself—as if the central entheogen of Asherah, which he claims was cannabis, was still in use by Ezra. Gad Barnea would argue (though I’m putting words in his mouth) that the entheogen wasn’t necessarily cannabis but rather, in general, an analogy to the Zoroastrian haoma, whose code name was “the burning bush.” Ezra supposedly presented it as a sacrament that Moses himself used during his initial sojourn at Horeb when he discovered Yahweh’s existence: “I am that I am.” Still, the idea is that Josiah’s reform wasn’t Deuteronomistic at all but rather a very simple reform—if it existed at all—of worship specifically for Yahweh, for purely economic reasons: so that the masses wouldn’t contribute to competing temples. Thus, he destroyed the other temples (those he could), and the only place allowed for worship was Yahweh’s temple. But he didn’t prohibit worship of other gods; he simply let locals worship other gods in Yahweh’s temple in the way they had in their own temples. Perhaps Jeremiah indeed opposed these other forms of worship, but this was later, and it’s unclear what made him change his mind. Or perhaps he never changed his mind; just as we have three different Isaiahs, perhaps there were two Jeremiahs, and the Jeremiah who condemns worship of other gods—even when directed toward Yahweh—is later, possibly even from the Second Temple period. Or perhaps, Adler would say, from the Hasmonean reform itself. Who knows.

In any case, this is when Judaism was founded. Judaism is exclusive worship of Yahweh, in Jerusalem alone, with binding Torah laws, an indoctrination and dissemination system (the synagogues), and priests who don’t always cooperate with this doctrine are considered sinners, and therefore their importance wanes compared to the rising importance and sanctity of the agents of Jewish doctrine—the rabbis. And the Temple, the priests’ place of worship, is perhaps a religious ideal, but more wishful thinking; hence the synagogue becomes a substitute for the Temple.

Adler argues in his new book that in the Persian and early Hellenistic periods, Yahweh worship coexisted with other cults and Yahwism was flexible. Only in the Hasmonean period did it become rigid and was adopted as state law (Lex Judaica). A religious purification began, and perhaps everything described in Josiah’s time actually happened in the Hasmonean period. The forcible Judaization under John Hyrcanus was retrojected into an imagined golden age, but Josiah is really who John Hyrcanus and the Hasmoneans wanted to be. And perhaps Ezra himself is a projection of a Hasmonean king since he was a priest, and his association with the Persian period was merely an attempt to grant prestige to these laws. But the laws were integrated into the existing Hellenistic reality, hence the similarity between Temple rituals and those that can be presented as Hellenistic—for example, Sukkot as a Dionysian procession, and Passover (as I myself argued in The Great Purple) as an Eleusinian procession.

In short, brace yourselves—impact coming soon!

הצטרפו לרשימת התפוצה שלנו


Comments

כתיבת תגובה

האימייל לא יוצג באתר. שדות החובה מסומנים *

×