The psychedelic history of Mormonism

The article The Entheogenic Origins of Mormonism: A Working Hypothesis was published in 2019 in the Journal of Psychedelic Studies. This groundbreaking article presents the hypothesis of possible entheogen use in early Mormonism, particularly under the leadership of Joseph Smith. Robert T. Beckstead, one of the article’s authors, had already proposed a similar idea in 2007 during a lecture titled Restoration and the Sacred Mushroom at the Sunstone Symposium. In 2017, Bryce Blankenagel and Cody Noconi presented a paper titled Revelation Through Hallucination at another Sunstone Symposium, expanding on these ideas and focusing on the connection between psychedelic use and Joseph Smith’s religious revelations.

The 2019 article was essentially a collaborative effort by these three authors. It marked the first time this idea was presented systematically and academically, combining historical documentation, visionary accounts, and anthropological theories. Assisting them in the anthropological and phenomenological aspects of psychedelics was Dr. Michael Winkelman, a former professor at Arizona State University and a prominent researcher in medical anthropology and consciousness studies in the “new wave of psychedelics.” If you’re familiar with the theory that cross-cultural shamanism is the fundamental component of religion, and that early philosophers and prophets of Israel were essentially shamans in the guise of religious scholars, then you are already acquainted with Michael Winkelman. As early as the 1990s, Winkelman published groundbreaking articles, such as Shamans, Priests, and Witches: A Cross-Cultural Study of Magico-Religious Practitioners.

The article’s central claim is that Joseph Smith used entheogens (psychedelics) as part of the religious rituals of early Mormonism to encourage visionary spiritual experiences among his followers. Psychedelic use was common in 19th-century folk medicine, particularly in the regions where early Mormons settled. Substances such as Datura and psilocybin mushrooms were available in areas of Mormon settlement. The Smith family had a background in herbal medicine and magical practices. Emma Smith, Joseph’s wife, was known to use ingredients such as Datura in “healing salves.” Their grandchildren reported the use of psychoactive medicinal drinks, including beer infused with ginseng and lobelia.

Based on these accounts, as well as Joseph Smith’s descriptions, central visions in Mormon doctrine—such as the revelation of the Three Degrees of Glory (as described in Doctrine and Covenants 76)—could be interpreted as having been written under the influence of psychoactive substances. Physical symptoms and descriptions of these experiences resemble those of psychedelics, as described in other reports of religious visionary experiences and psychedelic medicine. Other stories from early Mormon history, such as the dedication of the Kirtland Temple in Ohio, where about 500 participants reported angelic visions, suggest that wine used in these ceremonies might have been infused with Datura. These theories rely on indirect evidence and intersecting theories in psychology, anthropology, and religion. They seem plausible when viewed in the context of 19th-century alternative medicine and its connection to religion, as well as parallel theories about visionary experiences in the history of religion.

For example, Spiritualism believed in healing through supernatural means. The Adventist movement promoted the use of herbal medicine for treatment. Christians in general viewed healing as a part of faith in miracles. At the time, miracles were phenomena that could not be explained by contemporary scientific knowledge, and the botany of these plants was not well understood. Thus, the side effects of these plants were often considered miraculous. Furthermore, in rural areas of the 19th century, where interactions with Indigenous peoples occurred, a form of syncretism developed. Indigenous people integrated Christianity into their rituals, creating a form of Christianity that incorporated native ceremonies (e.g., the Peyote Church). Conversely, rural Europeans gained some understanding of local herbal medicine, including the mind-altering effects of plants used by Indigenous peoples.

This is well and good, except for one point: Mormonism is one of the most strongly opposed religious movements to the use of drugs or unregulated medications. Visionary experiences are generally not accepted within Mormon values, which emphasize moral and physical health. The Word of Wisdom, introduced by Joseph Smith in 1833, is a dietary and spiritual guide recorded in the Mormon scripture Doctrine and Covenants (Section 89). This moral and dietary code instructs church members to maintain their physical and spiritual health. It prohibits alcohol, tobacco, coffee, and tea, which are considered harmful physically and mentally. Instead, it encourages the consumption of wholesome substances like whole grains, fruits, vegetables, and meat in moderation. The body is viewed as a temple that must be respected and cared for through preventive medicine, physical activity, self-discipline, and community support.

Joseph Smith himself! How do we explain this apparent contradiction? First, it is not certain that it was Smith himself or during the period in question. Scholars of Mormonism challenge the claim that Doctrine and Covenants was written as a single, unified text. Instead, they argue that it was compiled over the 19th century and edited by various hands. The article agrees with this and suggests that after Smith’s assassination, Mormonism underwent a transformation. It can be seen as a reform or simply as an adjustment. During Smith’s life, he was the main attraction. To promote the new religion, he actively participated in rituals, and the use of entheogens was a “shortcut”—whether participants knew about it or not. This helped create powerful spiritual experiences. After his death, his charisma and practices disappeared. His successors, particularly Brigham Young, could not replicate them—perhaps they didn’t know how, or perhaps they didn’t want to. Faced with external challenges, Mormon leaders emphasized community structure and strict rules, focusing on preserving the religion rather than achieving extraordinary spiritual experiences.

During this period, the principles of the Word of Wisdom were further developed and institutionalized. Was it originally so strict about entheogens? It is impossible to know. It is also unclear whether they understood which substances caused these religious experiences and what their nature was. Drugs in the modern, synthetic sense did not exist at the time. Consequently, people had to be kept away from substances that were potentially dangerous without proper knowledge or supervision. Authority became an essential component of the approach to entheogens. Joseph Smith may have developed expertise as an herbalist or had connections to herbalists who discovered the “Holy Grail.” His successors likely did not.

Public opinion at the time viewed the use of mind-altering substances, particularly in a religious context, as witchcraft or paganism. This suspicion contributed to social unrest, violence, and eventually the assassination of Smith. This hostility also forced the Mormons to relocate multiple times, as public opposition followed them, at least until they moderated their practices, including abandoning polygamy and adhering to American laws. The same evolution may have happened with drugs.

Bryce Blankenagel has since become the host of popular anti-Mormon podcasts such as Naked Mormonism and Glass Box. Cody Noconi authored a 500-page book titled The Psychedelic History of Mormonism, Magic, and Drugs. Both continued publishing articles and participating in events like the Sunstone Symposium, an annual conference focused on Mormon studies. Together with Brandon Crockett, another podcaster in the field of Mormon criticism, Noconi co-produced a 40-minute documentary titled EntheoMagus, which explores this topic further and adds another chapter to the study of entheogens in Christianity.

הצטרפו לרשימת התפוצה שלנו


Comments

כתיבת תגובה

האימייל לא יוצג באתר. שדות החובה מסומנים *

×