I apologize in advance for writing a book review about a book I haven’t actually read. The book in question is The Tawny One: Soma, Haoma, and Ayahuasca by the British scholar Matthew Clark (from the University of London). Unfortunately, I couldn’t get my hands on this book (even though it’s available on Kindle for $18). What I’m writing here is primarily based on reviews I’ve read and an article Clark published in 2019 in the Journal of Psychedelic Studies, which was released after the book (published in 2017) and likely covers the same topics, perhaps even more extensively.
Clark’s main claim is that soma/haoma, the ritual drink of Vedic and Zoroastrian religions, was not derived from a single plant, as previous theories suggested, but rather was a mixture of psychoactive plants. He compares the drink to ayahuasca from South America, which combines MAO inhibitors with DMT-rich plants, and argues that soma/haoma functioned as an “ayahuasca analogue.” Clark proposes that this mixture was intended to produce psychedelic experiences in religious rituals, highlighting the physiological, cognitive, and spiritual effects of the plants.
While earlier research tried to identify soma/haoma as a single plant, such as ephedra, Amanita muscaria, or even cannabis, Clark shifts the discussion by proposing a multi-plant approach. He relies on textual evidence from the Vedic and Avestan scriptures, which suggest that soma/haoma was described as a drink prepared from various plants. This approach resolves contradictions found in previous attempts to identify the “real” plant behind the drink.
Another innovation in Clark’s work is his comparison of soma/haoma to rituals in other cultures, such as ayahuasca in South America and the kykeon in Greek mystery rites. Clark argues that psychedelic experiences were central to religious rituals across the ancient world and that soma/haoma was part of this global tradition. According to him, similar botanical knowledge was likely available in Central Asia during the Bronze Age.
Vedic accounts describe soma as a drink made from stems with nodes (parvan), which were crushed and dissolved in water. Clark emphasizes that in both the Vedic and Avestan corpora, soma/haoma is occasionally described as having “many kinds,” strengthening the multi-plant hypothesis. To demonstrate the possible connection to ayahuasca, Clark shows that plants like Syrian rue (Peganum harmala) and Desmodium gangeticum could provide similar psychedelic properties. He also mentions that some grasses, such as Kuśa, might have served as DMT sources, while MAO inhibitors could have come from plants like Tinospora cordifolia.
The ayahuasca analogue hypothesis represents a significant shift in the discussion around soma/haoma, moving from the identification of a single plant to examining plant mixtures. Although this hypothesis is not definitively proven and remains controversial, it offers a broader framework for studying the roles of psychoactive plants in religious rituals. The critiques of this analogy focus on its reliance on comparative culture rather than deep textual interpretation, and its comparisons are seen as culturally irrelevant to India and Persia. Additionally, the lack of comprehensive chemical research on the mentioned plants limits the ability to substantiate his claims conclusively. And yet.
הצטרפו לרשימת התפוצה שלנו

כתיבת תגובה