An Earthquake? Anthropologist Bernd Brabec de Mori, who lived among Western Amazonian tribes, challenges the common assumption: the use of ayahuasca in the region is not an ancient tradition spanning thousands of years, but rather a phenomenon that spread mainly over the past 300 years. According to him, the Shipibo people altered their stories to satisfy tourists and researchers, providing information tailored to foreign expectations rather than reflecting their actual lived traditions. The myth of long-standing ayahuasca use, he argues, spread partly due to missionary activity and the rubber industry's expansion.
Two studies are presented that support his claim: those of Martin Fortier and Andy Letcher. Fortier argued that only 5% of Indigenous cultures in the Americas used psychedelics before the Columbian era, and only 1% worldwide — and even that was considered a generous estimate. Andy Letcher, meanwhile, confirmed the use of psychedelic mushrooms in only two places: pre-Columbian Mexico and among small groups in northern Eurasia with the Amanita muscaria mushroom. In contrast, Michael Winkelman does not completely dismiss the idea and claims there are indeed scattered signs of psychedelic cults in mythology, cave art, and ancient rituals. However, most of the "evidence" we commonly refer to is based on highly speculative interpretations — such as mushrooms that might actually represent genitalia, or modern reconstructions of ancient paintings, often heavily embellished.
The studies supporting the claim that psychedelic use in antiquity was extremely rare were conducted independently, using accepted academic methods and critical analysis. On the other hand, the broader claims of widespread ancient psychedelic use are largely based on weak evidence, romanticized interpretations, or economic interests — such as promoting psychedelic tourism or magazine-style sensationalism, as seen in the case of R. Gordon Wasson.
Moreover, the popular attempt to link traditional shamanism with modern psychotherapy is largely misleading: in reality, psychedelic use among shamans was usually related to battling evil spirits, predicting weather, or performing magical rituals — not to treating personal emotional issues, as in Western psychotherapy.
הצטרפו לרשימת התפוצה שלנו

כתיבת תגובה