Next week, we are going to hear about the world’s oldest beer, discovered around 12,000 years ago at a Natufian site (Raqefet Cave in the Carmel). But it's worth noting another Natufian site where a grain-based product was found, shedding light on Natufian grain usage that predates the domestication of grains. Once we understand this, we need to ask why it happened, or in other words, why was there a need to domesticate grains in the first place? An intriguing question, which I look forward to exploring next week.
The oldest known flatbread in the world was found at Shubayqa 1 in northeastern Jordan, in the “Black Desert”, as part of a 2018 study by the University of Copenhagen. Specifically, charred remains of flatbread-like dough were uncovered. Through detailed analysis using microscopy and spectrometry, the researchers identified its components, including wild wheat and club-rush tubers, native plants from the Middle East, used as the base for the flatbread dough. These findings date back approximately 14,400 years (or up to 16,000 years according to conservative estimates), meaning this discovery predates the advent of agriculture by more than 4,000 years, proving that humans at that time already possessed knowledge of plant processing. This also shows that the Natufians lived not only in the western Levant, within Mediterranean woodland environments, but also in more arid regions. While this may seem unrelated, it demonstrates that Natufians inhabited a much wider geographic range than previously assumed, indicating that there were intercommunity connections across the Levant and possibly beyond.
Anyway, the Natufians used grinding and pounding tools to process grains and plant roots into flour, then created dough and baked it. This was an advanced food-processing technique involving peeling, grinding, and baking, suggesting that this flatbread was not merely a simple food item but held social and cultural significance. This indicates that the flatbread was likely not for everyday consumption but rather for a special ritual, raising the possibility that it was made for ceremonial purposes, or at least for a “special occasion”. It’s possible, then, that the need for grains for special or ritualistic events increased the pressure to develop organized agriculture, eventually leading to the domestication of grains. This implies that the motivation behind the agricultural revolution was, in fact, religious in nature. This is the central question.
The next section is my own thought, not related to the study. This idea suggests that humans domesticated grains because grains allowed for efficient experimentation with alcoholic fermentation—whether in making sourdough from improperly stored ground flour, or brewing beer from sprouted grains that had accidentally mixed with water. My own question is this: although alcohol may develop during the fermentation process of bread, the concentration is negligible, and it evaporates during baking. So, how can we present the preparation of flatbread for ritual purposes as something related to psychoactive ceremonies?
A speculative answer I give myself: if the bread was made from grains that, before being ground, were contaminated with mold or other psychoactive fungi, the flour from these grains could have retained their toxicity. There are reports from the Middle Ages of people consuming ergot-contaminated bread. So, who’s to say this flatbread wasn’t made from intentionally contaminated flour? This brings me closer to Brian Muraresku’s theory on the continuity of “sacramental ergot bread”.
הצטרפו לרשימת התפוצה שלנו

כתיבת תגובה