Throughout history, human beings have sought to understand their world and to control it – from comprehending the cycles of nature, to coping with anxiety and death, to preserving social order. Before the advent of modern science, the central tools of human culture were myth and ritual. The question, of course, is which came first – the myth or the ritual. To answer this, various approaches developed. We will focus on one particular theory, called the “Myth–Ritual Theory,” which holds that ancient religion was, in essence, a primitive science – an attempt to “bring order to things”, to understand the world and act upon it through symbolic and dramatic means.
This theory is broad and long-standing, and its formulation is not entirely unambiguous, but its underlying message regarding the evolution of religion is shared: first magic, then ritual, then myth explaining the ritual. The myth generally appears at a stage when the meaning of the ritual is no longer clear, when the ritual itself has already lost much of the original intent for which it was founded, surviving mainly by force of tradition. Still, as part of tradition, the ritual becomes the more important element, and as part of its rationalization, a narrative technique is developed to explain it – its meaning, its purpose, and of course its origin.
The myth also serves an educational role. Narrative and dramatic techniques tend to leave a deeper impression and are better retained in memory; stories are transmitted more effectively than illogical imitations. Stories also have the ability to become “memes” and to create new realities, even when separated from the need for which they were originally formed. In this way, works arise that are influenced by myths, or pay them homage, consciously or not. Cultures emerge that adopt a certain mode of thought and pass it on to realms beyond religious ritual – into daily life. Values are born from myths, and in turn create new myths. Thus we can see culture as a whole as a structure whose foundations lie in the original existence of magic – and that magic, in its essence, is an attempt to control reality and to resemble the gods. And if not to become gods ourselves, then at least to awaken and “program” the gods to maintain the world in accordance with our desires.
In the beginning, humans observed reality, noticed anomalies, and asked themselves what they meant. They gathered information, formulated a hypothesis, and tried to reproduce it through an experiment – much like a scientific method. Once they reached a scientific theory, they formulated a protocol. The function of this protocol was, on the one hand, to reproduce the discovered phenomenon, and on the other, to glorify the mechanism that brings it about (the personification of this mechanism is, of course, the “god”). The problem for this ancient scientist was that his information was incomplete, and even more so, he lacked an orderly scientific method. Thus: (a) he did not always succeed in reproducing his experiment and attributed its success to some higher power that would “help him” (in other words, this is the essence of prayer – the text that accompanies the ritual, which can be either a request or an ancient code intended to “program” or “bind” the god), and (b) as a novice, he made mistakes in gathering information, formulating the theory, and confronting it with existing bodies of knowledge. Communication between such groups of “scientists” was also limited, if it existed at all, so each was expected to work with a protocol devised by himself or by his tribe. The situation was grim, but common sense led different experimenters to reach generally similar conclusions – even if their scientific theories did not match their rivals’ from A to Z.
Exactly for this reason, despite the differences between cultures, we can still see similarities among them, because ultimately there is some form of common sense within us – or, if we speak in materialist terms, in our genetics there exists a mechanism that causes us to think in similar ways. The human brain and psychology developed along paths leading to the creation of shared structures (what anthropology calls the “biogenetic model”), which sometimes manifested in similar myths and, of course, similar rituals.
A short summary, or perhaps a fast-forward, because there is not enough space to continue this entire line of thought, so we will simply arrive at the conclusion: religion is the veneration of technology. When humans encounter a new technology, they experience a shock that causes them to “recalculate the route,” to understand whether the technology helps or harms them. Once they understand that the technology is beneficial, they attempt to reverse-engineer it. Once they see that it is harmful, they try to find protections against it – usually also through reverse engineering. Sometimes it is unclear whether the technology harms or benefits them, and so over time their behavior toward it changes, in a chronicle of cognitive dissonance whose end is an “Eureka” moment. As the pace of discovery of such technologies increases, and the mental load of determining whether each new technology is beneficial or harmful likewise increases, humans enter greater and greater anxiety, which manifests in changes in their behavior and in their way of coping with these innovations.
As a side note: the connection between this theory and the study of entheogens becomes more apparent when we look at the timeline. Both theories were born around the same period – at the turn of the 19th and 20th centuries – declined around the same time in the 1960s, and flourished again under similar circumstances: the revival of ideas that trace the development of religion through the prism of myths about death and rebirth, which, as we recall, are analogous to the psychedelic experience.
הצטרפו לרשימת התפוצה שלנו


כתיבת תגובה