Christopher Partridge is a professor at Lancaster University specializing in the intersection between religious studies and popular culture—naturally, with a focus on New Age spirituality and renewed expressions of ancient ideas, especially religious ones that have undergone secularization, or religious ideas that, according to some, were unjustly secularized and should now be restored to their foundations (aka fundementals). In short, as I see it, he’s a sort of Israeli scholar Tomer Persico–type figure.
I heard about his new book, "Cannabis, Sacred and Profane", from Chris Bennett, who published a sharp critique of it two days ago. I haven’t yet read the book myself—so I can’t agree or disagree—and given the e-book’s price, I don’t plan to spend my money on it, at least not for now. A shame. But I have read other reviews of it in parallel, and I have a general sense of what it’s about. I’ll first outline my understanding, then turn to Bennett’s critique, with a short summary.
First, the book’s title alludes to the title of a work by Mircea Eliade—as if to signal an intention: to analyze the historical attitudes toward cannabis along two parallel tracks. On the one hand, a religious attitude, in which cannabis connects to a mystical and ritual quality; on the other hand, a secular attitude, in which cannabis becomes an instrument for utilitarian purposes such as medicine, bureaucracy, economy, and, of course, leisure.
The fact that cannabis was unknown in Europe before the Crusaders’ encounter with the East made attitudes toward it inherently Orientalist: it was mysterious and might serve as a tool to deepen spiritual experience when used by Muslims—but, hey, these are Muslims, and they are “the other”, not us. As such, they symbolize everything that is not us—Eastern temperament, Eastern thinking, Eastern worldview—which in European eyes meant excitable, irrational, and therefore wrong and mad. Anyone who used these substances, even if they sought what Muslims found in them, would fail; and if they succeeded, they would “become Muslim”, meaning an enemy of Christianity.
This hostile stance toward cannabis persisted—even after being secularized—into hostility toward the plant as merely a “drug”. It was emptied of meaning, and even if it had meaning, that meaning was linked to alien spirituality.
From here, Partridge moves toward the twentieth century: anything perceived as foreign was associated with cannabis, and attitudes toward it and toward those who used it, traded it, or favored it were dictated by this negative view. This became a self-fulfilling prophecy: because the establishment distanced itself from the substance, it left meeting the demand for it in the hands of the anti-establishment. Naturally, then, cannabis became associated with whatever the establishment deemed negative—organized crime, political dissidents, and, of course, rival powers. Those groups also used it as a means to “poison” establishment supporters.
This, in turn, became a reason to use it: disappointment with the establishment and a search for alternatives—not necessarily the ones already “on the shelf”, but also those we seek and invent ourselves, what today is called "New Age". This is the root of cannabis’ adoption today by new spiritual seekers—a way to fill an anemic spiritual experience with non-institutional content. Being outside the institution, it is “virgin” and untainted. It’s an opportunity to reconnect with this substance in the very way the establishment once sought to delegitimize, and perhaps to regain what the establishment stripped away—the religious experience.
In other words, Partridge gives a primarily sociological explanation for popular culture’s attitude toward cannabis. That’s fine, but here lies the critique: first, it’s a superficial explanation that flattens the religious experience into a quasi-political excuse within an imagined struggle. In Partridge’s view, a spiritual experience has no inherent authenticity; behind it lies mainly a political reaction.
Second—and this is the main criticism—Partridge misses the point. Cannabis was not rejected merely because it symbolized the absolute other, the foreign and threatening, but because it preserved a religious practice the Church sought to erase. Its ongoing marginalization is not simply cultural bias, but anti-entheogenic indoctrination.
Partridge presents modern spirituality as “epistemic resistance” to ideas promoted by colonialism, instead of seeing it as an attempt to reconstruct the original entheogenic religious experience—one not mediated by layers of hierarchy and bureaucracy. In such an experience, the only barriers between a person and direct contact with the numinous are failure to follow a ritual protocol, not failure to obey authority. That was the original religious experience, and this is the “sin” that new spirituality seeks to atone for.
The sin of colonialism was not only the injustices committed in the name of Christianity, but the doctrine that the religious experience must be mediated by the Church, and that the masses are not permitted to use it, only to witness it. Advocates of cannabis are not “sacralizing a plant they fetishize,” but rather “profaning a worldview that emptied the religious experience of its content and turned submission to authority into the real fetish.”
הצטרפו לרשימת התפוצה שלנו

כתיבת תגובה