Two references in Hugh Bowden's book, "Mystery Cults of the Ancient World" (2010), to the question of whether psychedelic drugs were consumed by Mysteries


"Before answering these questions, there is one more avenue of experience to explore. In the middle of the twentieth century, the Eleusinian Mysteries were approached from the standpoint of ethnomycology, that is, the study of the role of mushrooms in human society. The poet and mythographer Robert Graves was the first to suggest that the Eleusinian Mysteries might have involved hallucinogenic mushrooms. Then, in a book first published in 1978, a group of authors including Albert Hofmann, the scientist who first synthesized LSD, argued that the ‘secret’ of the Mysteries lay in the use of a hallucinogen related to LSD. The authors argued that the kykeon drunk by initiates contained psychoactive elements that were produced by the ergot fungus. The usual effects of ergot poisoning include painful convulsions, but the fungus generates chemicals including lysergic acid, and these can produce hallucinations. Although the hypothesis was not well received by classicists, it has continued to receive attention, and new studies of the theory continue to appear. There are, however, objections to this approach, both practical and theoretical.

The practical objection is that it has not been possible to recreate the hallucinogenic effects that the theory proposes. Ergot poisoning tends to be painful and often fatal at levels that might generate hallucinations. If the hallucinogens cannot be produced in modern laboratories, it is difficult to see how they could have been regularly and reliably created in ancient Eleusis.

The theoretical objection concerns the idea that identifying the drug somehow explains the meaning of the cult. Ancient and modern accounts of the Mysteries emphasize disorientation and dramatic visual experiences. It is conceivable that drugs might heighten these effects, but there is no reason to believe that the experience would lose its power in their absence. The cult of Dionysus was very much associated with alcohol, in the form of wine, but as we will see in a later chapter, it is not certain that wine did play a role in nocturnal Bacchic revels. The highly exaggerated account of Bacchic activity in Italy given by the Roman historian Livy (59 BC–AD 17) includes all kinds of theatrical effects, achieved by mechanical means. Athenians in the fifth century BC were able to generate spectacular visual effects in performances of tragedy and comedy that were put on in honor of Dionysus. If we are to look for an external explanation for the power of the Eleusinian experience, the theatre seems a better place to look than the kitchen or brewery." (Chapter 1)

"Modern enthusiasts have sometimes turned from sex to drugs in the search for the secrets of the mysteries. This is most effectively depicted in fiction. For instance, in Donna Tartt’s 1992 novel, "The Secret History", a group of students manage to recreate a state of Bacchic ecstasy through a combination of ritual actions and ingestion of mind-altering plants. Apparently more seriously, there have been claims that the hallucinogenic effects of ergot or other fungi had a central role in both the Eleusinian Mysteries and the mysteries of Mithras. Similarities have been identified, with more or less plausibility, between ancient mystery cults and modern rave culture, although here the focus has been on the use of intoxicants, which is questionable in ancient contexts, rather than the role of loud, rhythmic and repetitive music, which certainly was common to both. But the desire to identify a lost secret—something that, once it is correctly identified, will explain what a mystery cult was all about—is bound to fail. As we have seen repeatedly through this book, it is unlikely that any such lost secret ever existed. There were certainly objects and actions that were only meant to be seen by initiates, but knowing what these were would not necessarily help us to understand the mysteries. It is quite possible that within the surviving contradictory descriptions of the mysteries we actually have all the information there ever was. Rather than searching for lost secrets, we should examine what we do know." (Chapter 11)

הצטרפו לרשימת התפוצה שלנו


Comments

כתיבת תגובה

האימייל לא יוצג באתר. שדות החובה מסומנים *

×