The Numerology Behind the Number of Bulls Sacrificed During the Festival of Sukkot and the hidden greek connection

Sukkot is a unique festival, not only because it lasts seven days but primarily due to its distinctively abundant sacrificial offerings compared to other festivals. While on a typical holiday, one or two bulls, a ram, and seven lambs are sacrificed, sometimes with a single goat for sin offering, on Sukkot, each day’s sacrifice is a “jumbo” offering—two rams, fourteen lambs, a goat for a sin offering, and a decreasing arithmetic sequence of bulls, starting from 13 down to 7, over the span of seven days, totaling 70 bulls. This immediately raises the question: what is the purpose of this abundance, and what is the significance of the number 70? This number is clearly symbolic, so the question becomes: what does it mean, and is there a deliberate message?

The hebrew sages attempted to explain this by attributing the bulls to the "seventy nations", yet this reasoning is less than convincing due to its inconsistencies. Prof. Meir Bar-Ilan, in his book "Biblical Numerology" (2006), meticulously outlines these issues and concludes that without a doubt, the number 70 holds numerical significance, as does the fact that it’s a decreasing sequence. Since the sages overlook this aspect, their interpretation cannot suffice as a full explanation. So, what is the real explanation? Bar-Ilan suggests that the descending series symbolizes the purpose of the festival—atonement for the possible sins of the community, a ritual that systematically diminishes sin until reaching completeness, represented by seven. The purpose of atoning during Sukkot is to encourage God’s forgiveness for unknown sins as Israel is judged for rainfall, the ultimate blessing for the land, on "Hoshana Rabbah", the festival’s climax, with the seventh day offering seven bulls.

Bar-Ilan explains that the number 70 signifies totality, much like the number 22, which encompasses everything from aleph to tav (or alpha to omega). This is because 70 is a product of 10 and 7, where 10 represents the people, and 7 represents divine perfection. In Jewish terms, 10 symbolizes a “minyan” or a communal quorum, while 7 represents sanctity or purity. Thus, 70 unifies the divine and human realms, embodying the collective spirit of Israel, a concept echoed in Jewish mysticism as “God, the Torah, and Israel are one”

In numerology and religion, numbers represent “spiritual levels,” each with a dual aspect—the sacred and the profane. Hence, the 70 bulls symbolize the potential for collective atonement and the community’s ability to transform sin into holiness. The descending sequence, as mentioned, illustrates the gradual reduction of sin until its final eradication, which is Bar-Ilan’s main thesis.

Initially, this may seem like a beautiful “d’var Torah” fit for a holiday table. However, there are deeper Pythagorean roots to this mysticism, connecting numerology to religious meaning. Bar-Ilan briefly outlines this, particularly in relation to how, for later Pythagoreans, the number 10 was problematic because it was considered imperfect and thus symbolized humanity, in contrast to the divine 7. However, beyond these anecdotes, he does not elaborate on the Pythagorean basis of biblical numerology, which is his focus. He mentions that Maimonides, following Aristotle, mocked those who sought symbolic meaning in biblical numbers, arguing in The Guide for the Perplexed that “anyone who occupies themselves with inventing reasons for any of these particulars [regarding why this offering should be a lamb, that one a ram, and that their number should be a particular count] is engaging in a great delusion, adding more folly rather than eliminating it. Anyone who imagines that these details have reasons is as far from the truth as one who imagines that a commandment as a whole is not for a practical benefit”ץ Aristotle, notes Bar-Ilan, derides the Pythagoreans in his book Metaphysics, and perhaps also in his lost work on the Pythagoreans.

Yet Bar-Ilan does not accept Maimonides’ rejection of numerological interpretations, arguing that throughout the Bible, even in places unrelated to commandments but rather to straightforward reports on the number of sacrifices offered by various individuals or kings—in this case, Solomon—the number of sacrifices appears to be typological. It’s hard not to believe that there was intent, if not in the exact number sacrificed, then at least in the number recorded. In all cases, there are multiples of 7 or multiples (even powers) of 10. Naturally, he also references the classic rabbinic interpretation of the 70 bulls as evidence that even they were aware of the symbolic significance of these numbers.

In the past, I mentioned the parallel between Shavuot and Sukkot and the Eleusinian Mysteries, both major and minor. It turns out that numerology also supports this. As mentioned, there is a parallel between Shavuot and Sukkot. Both have sets of sevens, and various arithmetic operations on these sevens culminate in a peak moment called “Atzeret”. This is the name of the Shavuot festival as well as the eighth day. Generally, the number eight is unique only because it is the number that follows seven. In every instance where Judaism uses this number, it emphasizes the completion of the preceding seven. Both festivals illustrate the completion of sevens: a descending arithmetic series in Sukkot, with an additional day, or a squared progression of seven plus one in Shavuot.

However, the arithmetic series of Sukkot is somewhat more unique than just a descending sequence. Mathematically, this is an equation where the unknown is 7: a descending arithmetic series of 7 terms that ends with 7 and sums to 10 times 7. The equation is essentially an arithmetic series whose sum is x(2x – 1)/2 = 10x (following the sum of an arithmetic series). The only natural solution to this equation is 7. This emphasizes a deeper relationship with sevens, likely highlighting Sukkot’s precedence over Shavuot. Bar-Ilan spoke of the atonement process during Sukkot. This was probably also the case in the Greater Mystery. Originally, a 20-kilometer march took place from Athens to Eleusis, a lengthy journey during which participants underwent more complex purification rites, including passing through a narrow, deep water source. After the ritual immersion, various offerings, mainly from plants, and animal sacrifices, particularly pigs, were offered.

During Sukkot, there were numerous water rituals, as well as a grand procession (Simchat Beit HaShoevah). Each sacrifice included a specified number of “issarons” items (hebrew: one tenth) which were measures of grain offerings. Bar-Ilan points out an additional arithmetic sequence described in the Talmud, in Menachot, concerning someone who vowed to bring a grain offering without specifying its exact quantity. According to the lenient opinion, they bring the minimum required—a single offering with the maximum number of issarons (60). According to the stricter opinion, they bring a series from 1 to 60, totaling 1,830. If they didn’t specify the type of offering, they would bring this sequence five times, totaling 9,150. I mention this to emphasize the role of grain offerings. For Jews, the pig is taboo, and the cow holds the highest sanctity, making it the preferred sacrificial animal.

הצטרפו לרשימת התפוצה שלנו


Comments

כתיבת תגובה

האימייל לא יוצג באתר. שדות החובה מסומנים *

×