The importance of the Wow effect

Thomas Frost and Henry Ridgely Evans were two of the key figures behind the formation of the earliest historical conception of conjuring in its modern sense. Frost, a 19th-century British journalist and author, published Lives of the Conjurers in 1876, one of the first attempts to document the history of magic as an art form. Evans, an American enthusiast of conjuring and a writer active in the early 20th century, expanded on Frost’s work in The Old and the New Magic (1906). Both sought to trace the roots of illusionist performance from a modernist, critical—often even dismissive—perspective towards the cultures and societies that preceded the age of rationalism.

According to Frost and Evans, magic in antiquity and the Middle Ages was not perceived as a form of entertainment, but rather as a manifestation of genuine supernatural power. They claimed that early audiences—“the ignorant masses,” in their words—could not distinguish between a trick and reality, between illusion and miracle. They presented ancient conjurers, and often religious figures, as manipulators who exploited the naivety of their audiences to consolidate power. For them, magic was a tool of control, not a vehicle for wonder or aesthetic expression. Accordingly, they depicted ancient religious settings as stages for organized deceit, where “miracles” were produced using mechanical techniques—smoke, mirrors, pulleys, and acoustic tricks—designed to convince viewers they were witnessing divine phenomena.

In their view, ancient magic was not innocent or aesthetic entertainment but a deliberate mechanism of deception aimed at manipulating a naive public and subordinating it to religious authority. Priests and early magicians, they argued, used technological ruses to fabricate miracles and thereby gain spiritual authority. Magic, then, became a means of domination, not of wonder.

One of their main examples was the ancient Greek temples and what they interpreted as stage-managed illusions performed for captive audiences. They described how gods were made to appear to worshippers through the use of smoke and mirrors, and how temple doors opened suddenly accompanied by the sound of thunder, appearing to be caused by supernatural forces but in fact engineered through mechanical means. They exposed how ancient “wonders” were created using optical illusions, hydrostatics, and acoustics, claiming that in antiquity, trickery served to simulate miracles.

Today, their position is no longer dominant and has been largely rejected as a modern myth—an “historical illusion not created by magicians, but by historians of magic.” It rests on the assumption that the past was naive and that we, the moderns, are rational and superior. Their method was flawed because they did not examine the broader context of the examples they cited. They relied heavily on chronicles, folklore, and miracle stories found in uncritical religious texts, assuming that any performer of tricks was necessarily perceived as a sorcerer—and thus persecuted. Most notably, they failed to distinguish between theatrical magic (where the magician declares the illusion) and ritual or religious magic (which aims to convince the audience of its truth). As a result, they portrayed a simple juggler as potentially burned at the stake—if only there were proof he had been.

A telling example is the case of the girl from Cologne, recorded in Johannes Nider’s 15th-century Formicarius. She was said to have performed a magic trick—tearing a handkerchief and then restoring it. In reality, she was a woman who claimed to be Joan of Arc resurrected. She spoke out against the church and monarchy, carried weapons, drank excessively, and dressed as a man—behaviors considered scandalous, especially so soon after Joan of Arc’s execution for similar “crimes.” The illusions mentioned in her case were described merely as frivolous diversions and were not the grounds for her arrest.

This example, and many others like it, are analyzed in The Secret History of Magic: The True Story of the Deceptive Art by Peter Lamont and Jim Steinmeyer, which systematically dismantles the classic narrative of the history of magic.

So, if ancient performers were not actually trying to deceive credulous believers using temple-engineered technology, why did they stage such spectacles? The answer lies in what we previously described as Thauma—the moment of astonishment, the epiphany. That is, part of the game of “theophany” (the appearance of the god) is constructing the setting within the framework of “set and setting.” The goal was to give the initiate undergoing the mystery rite a total sensory experience, an amplified, even exaggerated scenario in which the encounter with the divine would not remain a mere idea but become a palpable, embodied reality. In a secular world, we may describe such an encounter differently—not as nirvana, catharsis, or groove—but the underlying intention remains the same: to create a felt, transformative experience.

הצטרפו לרשימת התפוצה שלנו


Comments

כתיבת תגובה

האימייל לא יוצג באתר. שדות החובה מסומנים *

×