In antiquity, dance was perceived as a deep cosmic, philosophical, and ritual mechanism. It was not seen at all as leisure, and although it was understood as an aesthetic art, this was aesthetics in the Platonic sense, as the telos of perfection, because dance was the symbol of perfection and of order. When people danced, they sought to connect to the order and restore it – order in the sense of coping with chaotic reality, and order also in the sense of social order, hierarchy, and conformity.
In choreography, everyone has a role; it matters where person A stands in the sequence and where B stands, and the fact that everyone moves in a synchronized way is not only because that is considered a “good” dance, but because this very thing exemplifies obedience. Obedience is a social tool whose meaning, at least in ancient Greece, is harmony with the laws of the polis – if you are a good dancer, you are a good citizen and obey the law, “law” in the broad sense of social conventions, which in ancient Greece also included social boundaries and gender and class distinctions. The sociologist Marcel Mauss called dance a “technique of the body”; in this sense, when the community moves together in agreed-upon steps, it does not explain the rules in words, but rather “burns in” the norms of behavior and belonging directly into the participants’ muscles. The physical, synchronized movement turns the individual into an organic part of the group.
But let us return to order within chaotic reality. Dance is considered order in the midst of disorder: it has rules, and the beauty of dance is that when the rules are fulfilled, everything appears harmonious and beautiful. This is how the world ought to exist, and indeed this is how it is always actually existing. The very fact that we perceive chaos is simply because we are not dancing. If we dance, the world will return to equilibrium. For dance is a kind of meditation; dance is a kind of prayer, and when we do not pray – and the god needs our prayer in order to maintain order in the world – that is our problem.
In more philosophical terms: the world was conceived as a state of eternal present in which, at every moment, equilibrium is maintained by means of a “dance of the gods.” Within this framework, the god conducts groups of stars that circle him along their paths in the celestial spheres, revolving around him in rows upon rows. Their revolutions are so precise and harmonious that the entire orchestration appears as a dance, in which the stars dance around the god in a line dance. And because astronomers noticed the astronomical phenomenon in which the planets seem to retreat from their path, called “retrograde motion,” this line dance was not just a matter of walking in a circle, but more like dancing the horah – that is, a few steps forward and one step back. In Greece this was called Chorus, and the god is in fact the lead dancer and the choreographer, the one who leads the dance and the one whom everyone “submits to.” By his Greek name he is the Choregos.
In Greek dance, the Choregos stood at the center while the dancers circled around him. In ancient Athens, the title “Choregos” was also given to wealthy citizens who took it upon themselves to pay out of pocket for the considerable expenses of training and costuming the chorus for civic festivals such as the Dionysia. This contribution was considered a public service that granted the sponsor great social and political prestige. In some cases, the sponsors received high honors, because this funding also had a religious function that the gods regarded favorably. The funding itself was called in Greek “liturgy,” and when the poleis were in a good economic situation, this contributed politically to the sponsors. As the years went by, especially during the Peloponnesian Wars and later in the Hellenistic period, the institution of the polis weakened, and therefore the sponsors increasingly received (and demanded) greater and more exaggerated honor, to the point that in some cases they were called “euergetes,” literally “benefactor,” but specifically a word that belongs to the semantic field of “savior.” That is, the Choregos was at times something bordering on a quasi-divine role, and later almost divine. A Choregos who financed the festival was sometimes rewarded with statues and monuments in his name, such as Lysicrates, who sponsored the chorus at the festival of Dionysus and in return was allowed to erect a “monument of remembrance,” the “Monument of Lysicrates,” which still stands today.
As noted, the Choregos is at once a philanthropist, a party producer, and a dancer. It is reasonable to assume that if there had been a sound system, he would also have been the DJ and the MC – if those had been the accepted marks of honor. Alongside dance competitions at religious festivals there were usually also competitions in sports, art, poetry, and so forth. Dance was therefore a recognized social ritual in ancient Greece, to the point that when philosophers wished to address their audiences, they preferred to use descriptions of choros – the same image we discussed earlier of the god surrounded by the heavenly bodies, the stars and constellations – as a philosophical image.
As an aside, one can say that in different philosophical models, the figure at the center of the circle can be identified with the astronomical conceptions current at the time: the geocentric model, according to which the god “crafts” the earth; the heliocentric model, in which the god is identified with Helios (the sun god); or the Pythagorean model, in which at the center of the universe there is a “central fire” embodied in the god. The Pythagorean model is the one that influenced the later Platonic conceptions of aesthetics, because the stars in fact move according to mathematical ratios, and precision is numerical precision. The music that accompanies the dance – the cosmic music – is also built on harmonious ratios. The entire mechanism is sacred, and in the dance itself we connect with this sacredness; the more precise and synchronized we are, the better, the more we merge with the cosmic rhythm.
In the terms of the study of religion, one can call dance “sympathetic magic.” But this is not only because the creation of the world itself is in fact the cue for the beginning of a wonderful symphony, and when you dance you model creation and encourage fertility. The sympathy here lies in the mechanism of surrender: creation is essentially the moment when God spoke and the world responded passively; the world became receptive to the divine utterance. The moment you dance and in effect surrender to the sound and lose control of yourself, the moment you hand over control to the rhythm itself, or to the music, which is the language of God, you join the order. The mode in which you are acted upon encourages God to become active, and thus you imitate creation – not because you create the world, but because you participate in creation. You program God to create the world anew. Dance is a kind of programming, a magic spell, or a kind of coercion of the god to return to the same state he was in during creation. If we liken this to Hegel’s master–slave dialectic: the slave controls the master through being controlled by him. Creation in fact requires both creator and created; the tango takes two, the leader and the led. The leading is the choreia; the circular dance is in fact that same turning of the gear wheels that the electric spark set in motion.
In the middle of the text we spoke of dance as prayer, which will take us out of chaotic reality and restore cosmic order. This is precisely why, in messianic imagery (perhaps I will deal with these in another post), eschatology is described as a cosmic dance: “In the future the Holy One, blessed be He, will dance at the head of a circle with the righteous in time to come” (Vayikra Rabbah, Parasha 11). For the present world is flawed; we are oppressed under the rule of hostile forces and a wicked government, but at the end of days, through our “theurgy,” our striving and longing for the good, we shall be redeemed. Then we, the pure souls, and our God will stand in a nuptial dance. And what is that striving? That is to say: the dance. That is to say, even more precisely: club culture holds acid parties as a “magical” protest act against an oppressive establishment. The oppression is cognitive / political / gendered / fill in the blank.
הצטרפו לרשימת התפוצה שלנו

כתיבת תגובה