The Evolutionary Impact of Agriculture: Vitamin D, Lactose Tolerance, and Genetic Adaptations in Early European Societies

Late-night thoughts, and I apologize in advance to those more knowledgeable in nutrition, seeking tips and corrections. From what I've read, the transition of European society from nomadic hunting to agriculture contributed to genetic changes manifested in lighter skin and lactose tolerance. I understand this is related to the amount of vitamin D in the farmers' diet and the fact that Europe has cloudy and wintry weather, leading to less sun exposure. To compensate, presumably by chance, the further north and closer to the sea, the more the European economy became dependent on fatty, vitamin D-rich fish.

The shift to agriculture significantly changed the lifestyle and genetic characteristics of the European population. This effect could have been even more pronounced if not for the passage of time and the intermingling of European populations, which softened the impact of genetic drift. Nevertheless, these genetic changes can still be identified, as demonstrated by the research published in Nature Magazine.

Agriculture allowed people to settle in fixed locations, establish villages and cities, and develop complex communities. Instead of relying on hunting and gathering, farmers cultivated grains, legumes, and domesticated animals, leading to a carbohydrate-rich diet. However, their reduced reliance on hunting and meat consumption led to decreased sources of vitamin D. To compensate, they began consuming dairy products. The human body is tolerant to lactose only in infancy, with tolerance diminishing thereafter. Those who continued to consume milk needed favorable genes enabling "lactase persistence". Genetically, populations with a shortage of animal products, especially during times when the land did not yield sufficient crops, turned to dairy products. Those who managed to adapt and survive developed this tolerance.

There are two types of vitamin D: animal-derived (D3) and plant-derived (D2). Plant-based vitamin D tends to break down more quickly, making animal-derived vitamin D more effective in raising and maintaining blood vitamin D levels. Milk, being an animal product, contains more vitamin D than the "poor" diet of plant-based agriculture. However, dairy products naturally contain less vitamin D than meat, so even those who consumed dairy still suffered from vitamin deficiency.

To compensate for this deficiency, the body began developing lighter skin pigmentation to allow more efficient vitamin D production under reduced sun exposure. Melanin, the pigment responsible for skin color, acts as a filter for UVB rays from the sun. In darker skin, higher melanin content reduces UVB penetration, decreasing vitamin D production. Conversely, lighter skin has lower melanin content, allowing more UVB penetration and increased vitamin D production.

In these regions, the cold climate led to clothing covering most of the body, further reducing sun exposure. This caused people in colder areas to become even lighter than the "default" lightness.

Vitamin D plays a central role in the proper functioning of the immune system. It helps regulate immune cell activity, contributing to an effective immune response. Vitamin D deficiency can weaken the immune system, increasing susceptibility to infections and diseases. Agriculture introduced new diseases, and vitamin D deficiency made the population vulnerable, leading survivors to develop special immunity to these diseases. This immunity likely developed with the onset of agriculture and was influenced by genetic drift, where diseases claimed many who hadn't developed immunity, leaving a population with a higher frequency of "resistant" genes.

I pondered whether there's a connection between blood vitamin D levels and tolerance to psychoactive substances. The only finding is that those with vitamin D deficiency develop intolerance to opioids, increasing pain sensitivity and leading to higher consumption of painkillers. However, there's no evidence linking agricultural society's diet to opium addiction, and generally, no indications of widespread opium addiction in antiquity, despite awareness of its excessive use dangers. Had I found any evidence, I might have speculated whether the nature of rituals and the quality of substances used were related to dietary habits. But that's advanced knowledge. Besides, the use of psychoactive substances was prevalent, according to hypotheses, long before humanity turned to agriculture.


My reason for contemplating this topic is to examine whether the chronic deficiency of vitamin D had any mental or cognitive effects on people and whether this led them to seek “remedial” solutions. There are, of course, studies that support this notion. For example, the well-known research on depressive individuals in the Arctic Circle who experience prolonged periods without sunlight during the months when the sun doesn’t rise. It is also known that people with vitamin D deficiency have a higher susceptibility to schizophrenia and other mental illnesses. The question remains whether there is a link between vitamin D levels in the blood and tolerance to psychoactive substances, and, more broadly, whether there is a circumstantial connection between the development of religion and the changes in human lifestyle. This is the thread of my thoughts.

הצטרפו לרשימת התפוצה שלנו


Comments

כתיבת תגובה

האימייל לא יוצג באתר. שדות החובה מסומנים *

×