marriage as private property, and free-sex as communist ideal

Kind of off-topic, in an earlier group discussion we had about the attitude towards nudity and I told about the assumption that nudity became something to be ashamed of as soon as the first cities were founded and the idea of ​​social (including religious) hierarchy was created, because the idea of ​​private property was born.

In Plato's dialogue The Republic, Plato discusses the ideal community and argues that a community of sharing prevents war, because violence and passion only began when they invented this concept of private property. The issue of marriage is also a type of private property and therefore, there should not be single family household in the ideal community. The early Christians took this to an extreme.

Add to this the fact that they believed that the way to be redeemed from original sin is by restoring the natural state of the innocence in which the human race was originally, and this innocence is a reality devoid of passions. Jesus is the ideal habit of a life without passions, and there were Christians like Ephrem the Syrian who claimed that this is the proof that an ideal life is a life of celibacy, as is the orthodox view today.

But not everyone was like that. There were also those who took an approach that they claimed was classically platonic, desire is private property, and therefore lack of desire is cooperative, and since marriage is also private property, then in a cooperative life marriage has no meaning and the ideal community is a community in which women are being shared as well (women are property).

This approach was led by a sage named Epiphanes, whom the church father Clemens of Alexandria tried to label as a heretic, but Kathy L. Gaca argues that he was actually a normative Christian, as most early Christians were. Clemens describes the sect of Carpocrates' disciples as sexually depraved precisely because they used to share their women, and he links Epiphanes to them. Epiphanes wrote a book called "On Justice", which he opens with "The righteousness of God is a kind of sharing along with equality". Cooperation is agape (ἀγάπη), the love that is at the core of the commandment "love your neighbor as yourself". The habit of love is supposed to be absolute, according to the Sermon on the Mount and therefore one should love every person regardless of who they are, both friend and enemy (that is, a parasite).

According to Gaca, the fathers of the church came later and were the ones who changed the political perception towards private property and as a result towards celibacy. In general, they revised the definition of the so-called "lifestyle of the apostles", which originally was something completely different and much more what we would call today "hippie".

הצטרפו לרשימת התפוצה שלנו


Comments

כתיבת תגובה

האימייל לא יוצג באתר. שדות החובה מסומנים *

×