Charles Stang from the Harvard Divinity School published a new paper titled "Psychedelic Futures and Altered States in the Religions of the Ancient Mediterranean". The main point Stang aims to refute is the idea that ancient peoples focused exclusively on psychedelics to achieve transcendental experiences. His argument is not that they didn’t use psychedelics, but rather that psychedelics were one element among many. Stang critiques the perspective that psychedelics were unique or unparalleled in their ability to induce states of consciousness unattainable by other means. He calls this perspective “psychedelic exceptionalism.” This term describes the notion that psychedelics are a unique, extraordinary, and sometimes superior tool for achieving transcendence, transformation, and altered states of consciousness compared to other methods.
Stang critiques this approach and argues: Psychedelics are neither the only nor the primary path to altering consciousness. Often, they serve as mere “catalysts” within a broader set of practices that include music, movement, mythology, and cultural orientation. The focus on psychedelics as exceptional overlooks the complexity and diversity of transcendental and spiritual practices, both in the ancient world and today.
According to Stang, Brian Muraresku embodies this “psychedelic exceptionalism” perspective in his book The Immortality Key: The Secret History of the Religion with No Name. Muraresku argues that psychedelics, such as ergot in the kykeon potion, were a central component of the Eleusinian Mysteries and other spiritual practices. He also claims that psychedelics were integral to the Christian Eucharist, a fact he believes was suppressed and erased by institutional Christianity. Stang identifies Muraresku as part of a broader movement that seeks legitimacy from the past while presenting psychedelics as a supreme or unique tool for altering consciousness. Stang refutes this, not only because Muraresku relies heavily on indirect evidence but also because he neglects the complex cultural frameworks surrounding these practices, focusing almost exclusively on a single, isolated component. Stang argues that the evidence does not support such claims, drawing on research in the history of religion and cognitive neuroscience.
In neuroscience, this field of study is known as neurophenomenology, which examines various ways to achieve altered states of consciousness. Such states can be attained not only through narcotics but also through diverse methods capable of bringing the brain to equivalent states, identifiable through mapping techniques. Stang highlights the 5E framework, which posits that consciousness arises from five interacting parameters:
- Embedded (rooted in social and environmental contexts),
- Embrained (driven by brain activity),
- Embodied (shaped by the physical body),
- Encultured (influenced by cultural and social systems),
- Extended (expanding beyond the self, incorporating external tools and technologies).
Stang argues that these principles applied to ancient realities as well.
Additionally, Stang cites two studies that align with his perspective:
1. Yulia Ustinova, in her books Caves and the Ancient Greek Mind and Divine Mania, demonstrates how the ancient Greeks employed a variety of techniques to achieve altered states of consciousness, such as descending into caves, inhaling vapors, engaging in music and movement, and more—not just through the use of drugs. Ustinova describes ancient Greece as a “polyphasic” culture, which valued altered states, in contrast to “monophasic” cultures like Republican Rome, which tended to suppress such experiences.
2. Wouter Hanegraaff, in his book Hermetic Spirituality and the Historical Imagination: Altered States of Knowledge in Late Antiquity (2022), examines how Hermetic Gnostics achieved transcendental experiences through altered states of consciousness. Hanegraaff shows that such experiences were not solely drug-induced; even when substances were used, they were not central but served as catalysts. For example, the kuphi incense facilitated dreamlike states, but its effects were combined with other practices such as controlled breathing, meditation, mental focus, and the recitation of philosophical texts to prepare participants spiritually.
Stang points out that such practices were not unique to antiquity; similar approaches are evident in later spiritual traditions, such as Sufism. He argues that the use of psychedelics or mind-altering substances has always been part of a larger, multifaceted system and has never stood as an isolated practice or the sole means of transformation. Thus, he critiques the modern focus on psychedelics as exceptional and instead emphasizes their integration into broader spiritual and cultural frameworks, both historically and in contemporary practice.
הצטרפו לרשימת התפוצה שלנו

כתיבת תגובה