Chris Bennett publishes a 60-page response to Dan McClellan on the question of identifying "kaneh bosem" as cannabis and accepting the archaeological evidence from Tel Arad, indicating that cannabis was included in Judaic worship as part of the sacred incense and anointing oil.
McClellan's argument is based on the premise that there is insufficient evidence to support Sula Benet's theory regarding the linguistic connection between the word "cannabis" and the biblical "kaneh bosem" and that the academic consensus holds that "kaneh" refers to a different plant, calamus. The fact that cannabis remains were found at Tel Arad does not constitute sufficient evidence that cannabis was regularly used in worship, and linguistic parallels in the ancient Near East do not prove anything.
Chris Bennett's main argument is that McClellan's decisiveness overlooks a multitude of evidence that is conveniently ignored. Benet's claim is not based solely on linguistic similarity but also on reconstructing the worship practices described throughout the Bible, which align with textual and archaeological evidence indicating the common worship practices in the ancient Near East. This reconstruction, and the connections drawn between the various cultures to which the findings are attributed, allows for mapping the cultural and linguistic transmission of cannabis worship over centuries. McClellan's dismissal of Benet's theory essentially proves that he either does not fully understand it or prefers to ignore it for the sake of conservatism, considering only the single mention of the "kaneh" in Exodus 30:23 and not the other references in Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, and the Song of Songs.
Bennett argues that the primary takeaway from Sula Benet's work, which McClellan blatantly ignores, is that the findings at Tel Arad illustrate how cannabis worship was rejected by Judaism due to its pagan connotations. This rejection implies that up until the time when the Tel Arad temple was abolished, and its altars desecrated and buried, such practices were accepted in Judah under foreign influence. Bennett argues that although this worship was rejected, it did not entirely disappear but underwent a process of occultation. This is evident in early Christianity and subsequently further rejected and defined as heresy in Gnosticism. At this point, Bennett mentions another theory, also dismissed by McClellan, that even the meaning of the term "Messiah" ("Christos") in the New Testament, and in ancient Greek generally, suggests the use of a psychoactive substance, meaning that anointing was essentially the use of an entheogen, proving that "kaneh" was such a substance.
The debate continues…
הצטרפו לרשימת התפוצה שלנו

כתיבת תגובה